Osinbajo Accuses Supreme Court of Inconsistency, Calls for Urgent Overhaul of Nigeria’s Justice System

Former Vice President Prof. Yemi Osinbajo has criticized the Supreme Court of Nigeria over what he described as growing inconsistencies and procedural rigidity that often undermine justice delivery in the country.

Speaking at a legal symposium in Abuja, Osinbajo emphasized that the primary purpose of any justice system is to serve the people, not to exalt technicalities or formalities that frustrate fairness.

“The essence of any justice system is to serve the people, not to glorify procedural formalities,” he said. “When technicalities take precedence over substance, justice is compromised — and that is what we must urgently correct.”

Osinbajo, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN) and former Attorney General of Lagos State, lamented that the Supreme Court’s pattern of judgments in recent times has raised concerns about consistency, predictability, and equity — key elements that form the foundation of public confidence in the judiciary.

He called for a comprehensive overhaul of the justice system, stressing the need for reforms that would make court processes more transparent, efficient, and responsive to the needs of ordinary citizens.

According to him, “A modern justice system must focus on truth, equity, and access — not on arcane rules that keep people trapped in endless litigation. The Supreme Court must lead this reform by example.”

Osinbajo’s comments have since stirred widespread reactions within legal and political circles. While some lawyers applauded his courage in speaking out against systemic flaws, others argued that the issues he raised reflect long-standing challenges rooted in Nigeria’s broader institutional culture.

Observers say his remarks could reignite national discussions around judicial reform, particularly regarding delays in adjudication, conflicting rulings, and the need to restore faith in the independence and credibility of the courts.

As the debate deepens, one thing remains clear: Osinbajo’s call has added weight to the growing demand for a justice system that truly delivers justice — not just judgments.